Vote 0004 Outcome

logo2 results - 143 valid votes

ANTS (7th place)
      Dominates SEAL [37 - 35]

SWIRL (1st place)
     Dominates ANTS [103 - 15]
     Dominates SEAL [104 - 16]
     Dominates OLD Logo [89 - 47]
     Dominates FIXED Chicken [92 - 36]
     Dominates DG [77 - 57]
     Dominates MODIFIED [84 - 36]
     Dominates FURTHER Discussion [104 - 27]

SEAL (8th place)
 
OLD Logo (3rd place)
     Dominates ANTS [88 - 22]
     Dominates SEAL [85 - 22]
     Dominates FIXED Chicken [69 - 46]
     Dominates MODIFIED [64 - 58]
     Dominates FURTHER Discussion [86 - 32]

FIXED Chicken (5th place)
      Dominates ANTS [72 - 18]
     Dominates SEAL [73 - 20]
     Dominates FURTHER Discussion [78 - 33]

DG (2nd place)
     Dominates ANTS [87 - 24]
     Dominates SEAL [91 - 17]
     Dominates OLD Logo [69 - 54]
     Dominates FIXED Chicken [74 - 43]
     Dominates MODIFIED [65 - 54]
     Dominates FURTHER Discussion [90 - 32]

MODIFIED (4th place)
      Dominates ANTS [67 - 22]
     Dominates SEAL [67 - 24]
     Dominates FIXED Chicken [54 - 48]
     Dominates FURTHER Discussion [72 - 38]

FURTHER Discussion (6th place)
      Dominates ANTS [56 - 39]
     Dominates SEAL [61 - 38]


"SWIRL" wins by dominating all others.
logo2 Final Vote Ack


                                                FURTHER Discussion ----------+
                                                          MODIFIED ---------+|
                                                                DG --------+||
                                                     FIXED Chicken -------+|||
                                                          OLD Logo ------+||||
                                                              SEAL -----+|||||
                                                             SWIRL ----+||||||
                                                              ANTS ---+|||||||
                                                                      ||||||||
93sam@debian.org                                       Steve McIntyre 13452768
ajk@debian.org                                 Antti-Juhani Kaijanaho --3421--
ajpg@debian.org                                           Andrew Gray 73261845
Anthony                                                               15-423-6
aph@debian.org                                          Adam Di Carlo -1----2-
aqy6633@is5.nyu.edu                               Alexander Yukhimets 82314756
araqnid@debian.org                                       Steve Haslam 51863427
azekulic@debian.org                                      Alen Zekulic -2-3---1
bjorn@brenander.pp.se                                 Bjorn Brenander -1------
blp@gnu.org                                                 Ben Pfaff -1-2----
bma@debian.org                                       Brian M. Almeida -1-----2
borco@borco-ei.eng.hokudai.ac.jp                      Ionutz Borcoman -3---124
brinkmd@debian.org                                   Marcus Brinkmann -1----2-
broonie@debian.org                                         Mark Brown 71835426
cab@studbox.uni-stuttgart.de                             Stefan Gybas ---1----
camm@enhanced.com                                        Camm Maguire -4-231-5
cas@taz.net.au                                          Craig Sanders -1-34-25
cech@atrey.karlin.mff.cuni.cz                               Petr Cech -3--2-14
cetus@snowball.ucd.ie                                  Nikita Schmidt --43-1-2
cgb@debian.org                                                        83526147
ch@debian.org                                       Christian Hammers -2---1--
che@debian.org                                         Ben Gertzfield 215-43--
Christoph.Martin@Uni-Mainz.DE                        Christoph Martin 41376258
clebars@debian.org                                 Christophe Le Bars 83751426
craig@red-bean.com                                    Craig Brozefsky 61735428
crow@debian.org                                       Stephen Crowley 68473152
dan@debian.org                                      Daniel Jacobowitz -12-----
dark@xs4all.nl                                       Richard Braakman ---132-4
dave@recursive.prestel.co.uk                              Dave Swegen -152-4-3
david@tm.tno.nl                                  David A. van Leeuwen 621453--
davidw@efn.org                                        David N. Welton 32---1-4
dexter@debian.org                                    Piotr Roszatycki ---1---2
dhd@maclinux.plcom.on.ca                         David Huggins-Daines 62341758
dirson@debian.org                                         Yann Dirson -2-3-1--
dmartin@ececs.uc.edu                                   Dale E. Martin -2----1-
dnn@debian.org                                             Dan Nguyen -1-54326
doogie@debian.org                                          Adam Heath 68721543
dres@dimensional.com                                  James LewisMoss 43-12---
dunham@gdl.msu.edu                                    Steven B Dunham 54-12-36
Ed.Lang@pcug.org.au                                    Edward C. Lang -1-3-2--
ed@debian.org                                      Ed G. Boraas [RSA] 1---2--3
edd@poboxes.com                                     Dirk Eddelbuettel -1-4-32-
ekinnee1@airmail.net                                     Erick Kinnee 71835426
espy@debian.org                                          Joel Klecker 71645832
fog@debian.org                                   Federico Di Gregorio -2--3-1-
fpeters@multimania.com                                Frederic Peters 23-1----
fuji@debian.org                                         KELEMEN Peter -2-43-1-
gecko@debian.org                                        Darren Benham -5-142-3
gibreel@debian.org                                     Stephen Zander -2---1--
gpp10@cam.ac.uk                                    Giuliano P Procida 1------2
grisu@debian.org                                       Michael Bramer ---231-4
haphazard@socket.net                                Gregory T. Norris -1-432--
harpo@udel.edu                                              Will Lowe 417532-6
hilliard@debian.org                                      Bob Hilliard ---2-1-3
hugo@debian.org                                             Hugo Haas -3-241--
ioannis@debian.org                                  Ioannis Tambouras ----12--
jdassen@wi.LeidenUniv.nl                          J.H.M. Dassen (Ray) 34812657
jdg@maths.qmw.ac.uk                                     Julian Gilbey ----2134
jeff@planetfall.com                                Jefferson E. Noxon -1---2--
jfs@dat.etsit.upm.es                  Javier Fernandez-Sanguino Pen~a 31854726
jim@federated.com                                           Jim Studt -1----2-
joel@rosdahl.net                                         Joel Rosdahl -3-45126
joey@infodrom.org                                      Martin Schulze --312---
joey@kite.ml.org                                            Joey Hess 2---13--
joy@cibalia.gkvk.hr                                       Josip Rodin -2---413
jplejacq@quoininc.com                              Jean Pierre LeJacq -1---2--
jrguez@arrakis.es                                      Jose Rodriguez --2341-5
jrv@vanzandt.mv.com                                James R. Van Zandt 7134652-
jtravs@debian.org                                        John Travers 1256437-
jwest@netnw.com                                          Jim Westveer -2-3---1
kabi@informatics.muni.cz                               Zdenek Kabelac -465-123
kawamura@debian.org                                    Takao KAWAMURA ---1-3-2
kevind@rahul.net                                         Kevin Dalley 12654738
kirk@debian.org                                         Kirk Hilliard -3-2---1
kitame@northeye.org                                     Takuro KITAME -4-1-2-3
kk@sesom.de                                             Klaus Kettner ---1-2-3
knghtbrd@debian.org                                     Joseph Carter -3--421-
koptein@et-inf.fho-emden.de                           Hartmut Koptein ---2-1--
Lalo                                                                  12--3-4-
laz@rjdk.com                                           Fredrik Juhlin -2--34-1
leutloff@debian.org                                Christian Leutloff 35612478
liw@iki.fi                                             Lars Wirzenius 64712358
lmoore@debian.org                                         lantz moore -2--341-
lohner@icd.teradyne.com                                   Nils Lohner ---21--3
lupus@debian.org                                         Paolo Molaro -2----1-
maehara@debian.org                                      Keita Maehara -346512-
martin.buck@bigfoot.com                                   Martin Buck ---3-12-
martinb@debian.org                                 Martin Bialasinski ---4213-
mblevin@debian.org                                      Mitch Blevins 73854126
meder@control.toronto.edu                             Christian Meder 73615428
Michael.Meskes@gmx.net                                 Michael Meskes -423615-
mmagallo@efis.ucr.ac.cr                           Marcelo E. Magallon ---42-13
moffatt@cs.rmit.edu.au                                 Hamish Moffatt -123----
n3eua@amsat.org                                                       -1-342--
n9mtb@concentric.net                                    Rob Tillotson 64-73215
nils@debian.org                                       Nils Rennebarth 51487326
ninf01@gel.usherb.ca                                   Fabien Ninoles 71634528
nsandver@debian.org                                 Nathan E. Sandver 64325178
oldw@debian.org                                        Tibor Koleszar 52736418
Oliver.Elphick@lfix.co.uk                              Oliver Elphick -243-1-5
pdm@freesoft.cz                                         Milan Zamazal ---2---1
peter@makholm.net                                       Peter Makholm -4-1-23-
pfrauenf@niederglatt.lugs.ch                     Philipp Frauenfelder 71346825
phil@hands.com                                        Philip G. Hands 62-4153-
plundis@debian.org                                       Per Lundberg 21-43--5
promera@cistron.nl                                     Michel Onstein -2---1-3
psg@debian.org                                      Peter S Galbraith -3-4521-
pvaneynd@debian.org                                   Peter Van Eynde -1----2-
quango@socomm.net                             Christopher N. Lawrence 53681247
rafael@icp.inpg.fr                                 Rafael Laboissiere 71654832
rcw@debian.org                                        Robert Woodcock 71843526
remco@debian.org                                   Remco van de Meent -321----
remi@debian.org                                         Remi Lefebvre 324---15
rhertzog@hrnet.fr                                     Raphaƫl Hertzog -43521--
roderick@argon.org                                 Roderick Schertler -1-----2
roland@debian.org                                    Roland Rosenfeld -1-234-5
roman@debian.org                                          Roman Hodek -2-3-1--
rover@debian.org                                    Roberto Lumbreras ---3-2-1
ruud@debian.org                                         Ruud de Rooij -2-34-15
salve@fnal.gov                                  Davide G. M. Salvetti 76823154
sauter@math.ukans.edu                                   Lonnie Sauter 75426138
shanson@shcon.com                                        Scott Hanson 75421638
shorty@debian.org                                                     81645327
srivasta@ieee.org                                    Manoj Srivastava 34812657
ssm@debian.org                                 Stig Sandbeck Mathisen -1------
sstrickl@resnet.gatech.edu                          Stevie Strickland 87512634
steve@debian.org                                       Steve Kostecke -1----23
susumu-o@super.win.ne.jp                                 Susumu OSAWA ---2-1--
synrg@sanctuary.nslug.ns.ca                             Ben Armstrong 73854126
Tapio.Lehtonen@IKI.FI                               Tapio J. Lehtonen ---1-2--
tew@nwu.edu                                                Ted Whalen 71864325
thaths@netscape.com                          Sudhakar Chandrasekharan 3264517-
thompd1@texhoma.net                               Dale James Thompson -2---1--
tjhukkan@iki.fi                                        Teemu Hukkanen -------1
tom@trap.mtview.ca.us                                        Tom Lear -2---1-3
torin@daft.com                               Darren/Torin/Who Ever... --4-132-
trd@cs.mu.oz.au                                            Tyson Dowd -2---31-
tv@debian.org                                          Tommi Virtanen 12-6-354
ugs@laci.net                                              Paul Serice ---2-1--
ukai@debian.or.jp                                      Fumitoshi UKAI -1------
warp@whitestar.soark.net                            Zephaniah E, Hull 73564218
wichert@wi.leidenuniv.nl                             Wichert Akkerman -1-23---
ypwong@alumni.cse.cuhk.edu.hk                   Anthony Yin Pong Wong -1---23-


Votes in error
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
aba@casema.net                                                 Joop Stakenborg
   ! Conflicting votes
acollin2@mookie.demon.co.uk                                     Ashley Collins
   ! Bad PGP or not PGP signed
adelarue@iname.com                                           Alexandre Delarue
   ! Bad PGP or not PGP signed
amos@gezernet.co.il                                               Amos Shapira
   ! Bad PGP or not PGP signed
andrew.hately@eurocontrol.be                                     Andrew Hately
   ! Bad PGP or not PGP signed
ang@mail.dotcom.fr                                             Anthony Ginepro
   ! Bad PGP or not PGP signed
apmarles@uwaterloo.ca                                      "Allison P. Marles"
   ! Bad PGP or not PGP signed
bailey@psn.net                                                    Scott Bailey
   ! Bad PGP or not PGP signed
bart@skypro.be                                                    Bart Demeyer
   ! Bad PGP or not PGP signed
bboett@erm1.u-strasbg.fr
   ! Bad PGP or not PGP signed
c680789@showme.missouri.edu                                      Andrei Ivanov
   ! Bad PGP or not PGP signed
chris@mathphys.fsk.uni-heidelberg.de
   ! Conflicting votes
chrisw@insnet.net                                                        Chris
   ! Bad PGP or not PGP signed
dale@sirranet.co.nz                                                  Dale Kemp
   ! Bad PGP or not PGP signed
dd@davedash.com                                                      Dave Dash
   ! Bad PGP or not PGP signed
dsew@packrat.aml.arizona.edu                                      David Sewell
   ! Bad PGP or not PGP signed
ean@novare.net                                               Ean R. Schuessler
   ! Bad PGP or not PGP signed
eesnault@netscape.net                                            Erwan Esnault
   ! Bad PGP or not PGP signed
fredrik@vegasys.net
   ! Bad PGP or not PGP signed
growler@netmeeting.net                                                 Growler
   ! Bad PGP or not PGP signed
gsteeves@gpu.srv.ualberta.ca                                             Geoff
   ! Bad PGP or not PGP signed
ISCOTT@cedelglobalservices.com
   ! Bad PGP or not PGP signed
ivank@wrq.com
   ! Bad PGP or not PGP signed
jlpeters@ecst.csuchico.edu                                 "James L. Peterson"
   ! Bad PGP or not PGP signed
jolsen@ptc.com
   ! Bad PGP or not PGP signed
jpelsner@hotmail.com                                                     "J E"
   ! Bad PGP or not PGP signed
kdonn@debian.org                                                Kevin Donnelly
   ! Conflicting votes
kejace@myself.com                                                      KEJ|ace
   ! Bad PGP or not PGP signed
kevincarson@home.com                                              Kevin Carson
   ! Bad PGP or not PGP signed
maggi@ien.it                                                      Sabino Maggi
   ! Bad PGP or not PGP signed
manz@intes.de
   ! Bad PGP or not PGP signed
marco@emha.de                                                            marco
   ! Bad PGP or not PGP signed
olf@biba.uni-bremen.de                                           "Olaf Peters"
   ! Bad PGP or not PGP signed
phill@internet-appliance.com                                     Phill Kenoyer
   ! Bad PGP or not PGP signed
rezac@icu.strath.ac.uk                                      Reza Cheshmehdoost
   ! Bad PGP or not PGP signed
rwh@ecr.mu.oz.au                                         Robert_William HUTTON
   ! Bad PGP or not PGP signed
shane.turner@iname.com                                            Shane Turner
   ! Bad PGP or not PGP signed
smayer@us.oracle.com                                               Steve Mayer
   ! Bad PGP or not PGP signed
swift@damien.warped-reality.com                                        "L. F."
   ! Bad PGP or not PGP signed
tres@rap.ucar.edu                                              Tres Hofmeister
   ! Bad PGP or not PGP signed
zur@edu.lahti.fi                                                 P.A. Knuutila
   ! Bad PGP or not PGP signed